Saturday, 9 June 2018

Tania versus Kelly

After I made my Grainline Studios Moss skirt, I did indeed fall down a denim skirt rabbit hole, and have made both Megan Nielsen's Tania Culottes and Kelly Skirt.  Here are my thoughts on both.

Both worn with a good old Tilly And The Buttons Agnes Top

Tania Culottes

These are made from a chambray fabric I bought on ebay.  I made version 2 (knee length) in a size small, but used the length from size extra small.  The pattern calls for 2.6m of fabric, I had 2.5m and cut this out by the skin of my teeth.  The pattern says 2.6m for all sizes on version 2, but it might be a bit tricky with the larger sizes, so 3 metres might be safer.



The most important thing I found was to label all the pattern pieces with front and back, as they all look so similar.  Also, I marked right and wrong sides as my fabric was the same on both. These came together really quickly, the instructions are brilliant, and the sizing is as on the pattern. 

The hem is supposed to be turned and pressed under twice, but as it's about 5 metres long, I didn't fancy that and used bias tape instead. 


Kelly Skirt

Again these are made from some chambray from ebay, and I made a size small.  The sizing is as on the pattern.  


This is a lovely pattern, and my favourite thing is the pockets.  They are the perfect size, and the instructions for sewing them are brilliant.  The pleats give the skirt a lovely shape, and are easy to sew.  


The instructions have interfacing the button placket as a guideline, rather than something that has to be done.  But I would always interface where I'm going to cut a buttonhole, so that's what I did.

Conclusions

I love both garments, but I surprised myself by liking Tania better.  This is because Kelly has a rectangle waistband that sits in the middle of the natural waist, and Tania has a contoured waistband, with the top of the waistband sitting at the natural waist.  I have always found contoured waistbands a bit more comfortable as I have a short torso, so Tania is my winner.

I thought these culottes might lose some volume as I couldn't wear a net petticoat under them, but the pleat at the front and back give them loads of movement.


They are basically a circle skirt, but culottes, so no worries about the hem being caught in a gust of wind - as beautifully demonstrated in the photo above!!


In fact, I loved Tania so much, I've already made a second pair from some linen/rayon fabric from Like Sew Amazing.  As it's linen it has slightly lose weave, and is slightly see-through, so I underlined it with some black cotton voile.  And clearly I need to make some more Agnes tops...





Have a great weekend!

Lynne

6 comments:

  1. Those culottes are fab! And I know I've said it before, but I do love that Tilly and the Buttons top a lot!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Helen! I love that top pattern too, and really need to make some more.

      Delete
  2. Lovely new skirt and culottes! Do you often buy fabric on eBay?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Stephanie! Yes, I buy from eBay quite regularly. There aren't many fabric shops in Northern Ireland, so pretty much all my fabric is bought online.

      Delete
  3. They all look great - I think the chambray culottes are my favourites though. Always good to have the fullness of a circle skirt without having to worry about the wind!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Ruth! The chambray culottes are my favourite too, and I've been wearing them a lot.

      Delete

Thank you for reading my blog! I love reading your comments, so please feel free to leave a comment if you have the time :) Lynne.